Zayday’s first order of business is a sleepover! Zayday and Grace’s plan is to play Truth or Dare so that she could get some answers to the mysteries that have been going on, but Chanel Three insist on playing Spin the Bottle. You see, No. 3 has been having strangefeelings and wants to kiss Predatory Lez. The two get their kiss, but later No. 3 tells her that she’s unable to have feelings and that falling in love with her would be dangerous.
The lights go off and all doors and windows are locked. Knowing that the Red Devil must be behind this, Chanel calls Chad. As Chad and his boys climb the ladder up to Chanel’s room, they spot the Red Devil. All climb to safety with the exception of the arm-less brother, who ends up getting his head chopped off by the killer.
The game of Truth or Dare commences and after humiliating Chanel No. 5 (her vagina used to/still does have teeth), Predatory Lez is asked what No. 3’s darkest secret is. Predatory Lez tells the others that Charles Manson is No. 3’s dad. The two argue and Predatory Lez is dared to take a nap in the bathtub. The Red Devil is waiting for her there and kills her, but not before revealing himself. When Predatory Lez sees who it is, she says, “I knew it. I knew it was you!” Next to get killed is Chanel No. 5’s boyfriend, Dodger. The group then find an underground tunnel and Zayday goes to check it out with Chanel. The Red Devil is there and almost kills Zayday, but Chanel saves her.
The following morning, the girls declare that the Red Devil won’t take any more lives and promise to stick together. The Red Devil watches from the window as the girls dance, you know, because the death of their friends shouldn’t stop the party!