Obrecht shows up at the Cassadine mansion for dinner with Britt and Nikolas. Spencer, who is dressed up as a pilgrim, is sad because he's not with Emma. As Britt sets the table, Obrecht cries about Faison being out there hungry, cold and alone. Faison is closer than they realize, he’s outside wearing a nice suit and spying on them through the window.
At Pentonville, Carly visits with Sonny. Carly has to tell Sonny about Michael renouncing his name and moving into the Quartermaine mansion. Sonny is hurt, but wants her to go home and enjoy the holiday with her family.
At the Quartermaine mansion, Sam brings Danny by to see Monica and Michael. Michael invites them to dinner, but she already has plans with Patrick and Elizabeth. Larry Ashton shows up as Sam is leaving and he asks Michael if that was Patrick Drake’s wife he just saw. Michael says no they aren’t married. Larry appears to be onto Patrick and Sam’s investigation of him. Later, Olivia, Dante and Lulu all arrive for dinner. As everyone gets ready to eat, Monica announces that one of the dishes caused the cook to come down with food poisoning, and as they don’t know which one it is, it all has to be thrown out. Fortunately Alice walks in to save the day with a stack of pizzas.
At Liz’s place, Jake/Jason answers the door to find Helena Cassadine standing there. She claims to be an old friend of the family, so he invites her in. Jake thinks she looks familiar and he wonders if they met before, explaining he’s lost his memory. She claims she just has one of those faces. Jake decides to go get Elizabeth, but when he leaves the room, Helena slips out. He unfortunately didn’t get her name to tell Elizabeth. Elizabeth thinks perhaps it was just a memory of his resurfacing. Jake knows the woman was real and heads to the door, thinking she couldn’t have gone far. When he opens it, Sam is standing there. Sam, Patrick and the kids head inside and Danny once again takes to Jake.
At Miscavige, Julian and Alexis find Luke confided in a straight jacket in his cell. Alexis works to free Luke from his straight jacket and asks about his visit from Helena. Luke says she let him live because he convinced her that he was still useful to her and the maniac that has stolen his life. Alexis says she knows what has been happening with the imposter as Julian filled her in. Luke figures out that Julian was in on the whole scheme and he wants to strangle him. Alexis tries to calm Luke down and tells Julian perhaps he should leave. Julian doesn’t want to leave her alone here, but will go. Julian tells Luke that he didn’t want to do this to him, that the imposter threatened his family and shot Lucas. Later Alexis wants to take Luke to General Hospital, but he refuses to go to another hospital. Alexis tells him then they are going straight to the station to see Anna.
Back at Wyndemere, Nathan arrives for dinner with his sister and Obrecht. Outside Helena appears and stops Faison from going inside, pointing out that Nathan is the police. She reminds him of the job he has to do. Faison says he doesn’t take orders from her, and she is supposed to be dealing with Jason Morgan. Helena warns him not to cause their plans to go up in smoke. Back in the mansion, everyone gets ready to sit down for dinner. Spencer realizes forgot his pilgrim hat, so Obrecht goes back to the living room to get it for him. Seeing Obrecht alone, Cesar takes the chance and reveals himself to her.
Back at Elizabeth’s, Helena returns and spies on the gang from the window as they eat dinner.
As the Quartermaine clan sits down to eat their pizza, Alexis arrives with a very special guest. Luke walks in and asks if they saved a slice for him. He then winks at Tracy.