Spencer and Emma have skipped school and gone to the Cassadine stables. Spencer has brought her there to show her his secret hiding place. He said he was hiding here the night of his father’s engagement party, the night he heard that man plotting against his uncle Sonny, the night she fell into danger. Spencer begs Emma for a second chance. Before she can answer, Nikolas and Britt discover them. Spencer stands up for Emma saying he made her skip school and come here, so she shouldn’t be punished.
Sam and Patrick go to the Port Charles bank to break into Larry’s safe deposit box. They pose as a newlywed couple in order to get access to the vault, and once left alone find Larry’s box. Inside the box is a second lock box that Sam attempts to open.
At the Quartermaine mansion, Lulu attempts to stall Larry from going to the bank. Lulu questions him about her father, but Larry tells Lulu and Tracy that he’s never met Luke Spencer. Lulu shows him a photo of her father asking if he’s ever seen this man. Larry says he has seen him, but only in a photo in this house. Larry leaves, and Lulu texts Patrick and Sam to warn them that Larry is on his way. Lulu tells Tracy that Patrick and Sam overheard Larry talking to Jerry Jacks on the phone discussing their Luke Spencer problem. They discuss what could be going on with Luke. Though Lulu has her doubts about her father, Tracy defends Luke and is sure he is innocent.
At the PCPD jail, Alexis arrives to see Julian, per Lucas’ request. Julian tells Alexis that he’s ready to tell her everything and name names. Julian recounts how the night of Nikolas’ party he did slip out to the stables to meet Luke about business, just as Tracy said. However not everything is as it appears. Julian tells Alexis that Luke Spencer is not actually Luke Spencer. Julian says someone else has taken Luke’s place.
At Miscavige, Luke is still locked in his cell and in a straight jacket. An orderly comes in to give him his medication, but Luke only pretends to take it. Luke has been spitting them out behind his bed. He plans to escape and find the snake that stuck him in here. Luke starts remembering his imposter’s visits and vows to kill him. He is tormented over how the imposter told him that he was doing his husbandly duties and taking care of Tracy in the sack. Luke becomes so enraged that he’s able to break free of his restraints. He then uses one of the buckles off his straight jacket to pick the lock of his cell. As he opens the door he comes face to face with his imposter.
Back at the Port Charles bank, Sam and Patrick get Lulu’s message just in time. As they go to leave the vault they run right into Larry. They are able to make their getaway and Sam hopes that Larry doesn’t figure out that she tampered with his lockbox. Back in the vault, Larry opens his box and the lockbox inside. He gets what he needs and leaves. Sam and Patrick return and claim they left something in the room, hoping to find if Ashton left any clues behind. They manage to get into his box and are stunned by what they find. Inside the box they find a jump drive and a photo of Faison.
Back the stables, Spencer and Emma are sent back to school, and Nikolas confides in Britt that he doesn’t know where Spencer gets this deceit from. Sloan, Anna and Obrecht then arrive and interrupt Britt and Nikolas mid-kiss. They are informed that Anna claims Faison is imprisoned in the stables. Nikolas can’t see how that’s possible, but Anna reveals a hidden trap door that leads to a cavern under the island. Obrecht says burying him there is savage and barbaric. Anna says he is still alive and has been given food and water. Sloan suggests they get him out of there, so they open up the door. Everyone is stunned to find Faison isn't there.