In Pentonville, Sonny comes face to face with Johnny. The two seem to make peace, even bonding over their hatred for Ava and love for Connie. However it turns out that Johnny is running the show in Pentonville, and he says he can’t appear weak to anyone on the inside. Johnny has his men rough Sonny up while he sits back and makes jokes.
At the PCPD, Anna, Dante and Nathan are preparing to transfer Faison to Pentonville by way of an armored wagon. Unfortunately a masked man in black grabs Sam and holds her hostage in exchange for the keys to the wagon. During the scuffle Nathan is shot in the shoulder. Anna orders Dante to throw the keys to the man, who throws Sam to the ground and takes off in the wagon. Anna and Sam see to Nathan while Dante goes after the wagon and Faison. Unfortunately he finds the wagon abandoned and no trace of Faison or the masked man. Lulu arrives on scene and learns that Nathan was shot. He’s taken to the hospital and Sam rides along with him. Anna tells Dante that Faison has been spotted at the docks, so they head after him.
At Liz’s house, Nikolas is puzzled as to why Helena came to see Jake. He wants to question Jake, but Jake is out looking for work. Nicholas can't believe Liz is letting a complete stranger live with her and that Jake could be a psychopath. Liz tells Nikolas that he is one to talk, as he trusted Britt for a second time only to get burned. She thinks Jake at least has a clean slate.
On the docks, Helena learns Britt is leaving town with Obrecht and Faison in order to escape prosecution by Nikolas. Helena admires Britt’s determination where Nikolas is concerned, but she is not happy to learn Spencer could have been put in danger. Obrecht assures her that Spencer is fine. Just then Spencer arrives on the docks having run away from home after learning Nikolas kicked Britt out. He begs to go with her, but Helena orders him home. Spencer back talks to Helena, not knowing she is his great grandmother. Helena puts him in his place and orders him back home. Britt and Spencer share a tearful goodbye. She gives him back her engagement ring and urges Spencer to give it to his own someone special one day. After Spencer leaves the masked man arrives with Faison. Helena takes the man into a warehouse,where he is revealed to be Jake/Jason. Helena orders him to return to Elizabeth’s home and that per his conditioning he will remember none of this. Meanwhile Faison informs Britt and Obrecht that Nathan was shot during his escape. Britt wants to stay behind, but Obrecht insists she be the one to stay. She and Britt say goodbye, and Obrecht tells Faison she’s waited this long to be with him so she can wait a little longer. Obrecht says she gave up Nathan once and she can’t do it again.
Jake returns to Elizabeth’s house, where she asks him how the job search went.